Plans abounding for new sports stadiums across the US, carrying hefty public costs
Plans abounding for new sports stadiums across the US, carrying hefty public costs
FILE - Fans are pictured outside American Family Field before a baseball game between the Milwaukee Brewers and the Chicago Cubs, April 12, 2021, in Milwaukee. Proposals for new and improved sports stadiums are proliferating across the U.S. — and could come with a hefty price tag for taxpayers. (AP Photo/Morry Gash, File)
FILE - From left, Buffalo Bills head coach Sean McDermott, General Manager Brandon Beane, EVP/Chief Operating Officer Ron Raccuia, owner Terry Pegula, New York Governor Kathy Hochul, Erie County Executive Mark Poloncarz and NFL commissioner Roger Goodell participate in the groundbreaking ceremony at the site of the new Bills Stadium in Orchard Park, N.Y., Monday June 5, 2023. Proposals for new and improved sports stadiums are proliferating across the U.S. — and could come with a hefty price tag for taxpayers. This past year alone, roughly a dozen Major League Baseball and National Football League franchises took steps toward building new stadiums or making major renovations to their current ones. (AP Photo/Jeffrey T. Barnes, File)
FILE - Kansas City Royals baseball team officials and their consultants talk about proposals for a new stadium to replace Kaufmann Stadium which has been home to the team for more than 50 years during a news conference, Tuesday, Aug. 22, 2023, in Kansas City, Mo. The proposal to build a new Royals stadium closer to downtown Kansas City spurred thousands of fans to join a Facebook site rallying to keep the current stadium. The hefty public financing forms part of their objection. (AP Photo/Charlie Riedel, File)
FILE - The Tennessee Titans play an NFL football game against the Houston Texans at Nissan Stadium in Nashville, Tenn., Sept. 16, 2018. Proposals for new and improved sports stadiums are proliferating across the U.S. — and could come with a hefty price tag for taxpayers. The Titans new $2.1 billion domed stadium includes $760 million in local bonds the Nashville City Council approved to go with $500 million in state bonds.(AP Photo/James Kenney, File)
FILE - Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers signs Assembly Bill 438 and Assembly Bill 439 at American Family Field Tuesday, Dec. 5, 2023, in Milwaukee. Proposals for new and improved sports stadiums are proliferating across the U.S. — and could come with a hefty price tag for taxpayers. (AP Photo/Morry Gash)
Ken Rettberg, a longtime Oakland A’s fan, is frustrated by the baseball team’s planned departure for Las Vegas and the taxpayer dollars that are subsidizing new sports venues. Pleasant Hill, Calif. Dec. 19, 2023. (AP Photo/Terry Chea)
FILE - Fans are pictured outside American Family Field before a baseball game between the Milwaukee Brewers and the Chicago Cubs, April 12, 2021, in Milwaukee. Proposals for new and improved sports stadiums are proliferating across the U.S. — and could come with a hefty price tag for taxpayers. (AP Photo/Morry Gash, File)
FILE - Fans are pictured outside American Family Field before a baseball game between the Milwaukee Brewers and the Chicago Cubs, April 12, 2021, in Milwaukee. Proposals for new and improved sports stadiums are proliferating across the U.S. — and could come with a hefty price tag for taxpayers. (AP Photo/Morry Gash, File)
FILE - From left, Buffalo Bills head coach Sean McDermott, General Manager Brandon Beane, EVP/Chief Operating Officer Ron Raccuia, owner Terry Pegula, New York Governor Kathy Hochul, Erie County Executive Mark Poloncarz and NFL commissioner Roger Goodell participate in the groundbreaking ceremony at the site of the new Bills Stadium in Orchard Park, N.Y., Monday June 5, 2023. Proposals for new and improved sports stadiums are proliferating across the U.S. — and could come with a hefty price tag for taxpayers. This past year alone, roughly a dozen Major League Baseball and National Football League franchises took steps toward building new stadiums or making major renovations to their current ones. (AP Photo/Jeffrey T. Barnes, File)
FILE - From left, Buffalo Bills head coach Sean McDermott, General Manager Brandon Beane, EVP/Chief Operating Officer Ron Raccuia, owner Terry Pegula, New York Governor Kathy Hochul, Erie County Executive Mark Poloncarz and NFL commissioner Roger Goodell participate in the groundbreaking ceremony at the site of the new Bills Stadium in Orchard Park, N.Y., Monday June 5, 2023. Proposals for new and improved sports stadiums are proliferating across the U.S. — and could come with a hefty price tag for taxpayers. This past year alone, roughly a dozen Major League Baseball and National Football League franchises took steps toward building new stadiums or making major renovations to their current ones. (AP Photo/Jeffrey T. Barnes, File)
FILE - Kansas City Royals baseball team officials and their consultants talk about proposals for a new stadium to replace Kaufmann Stadium which has been home to the team for more than 50 years during a news conference, Tuesday, Aug. 22, 2023, in Kansas City, Mo. The proposal to build a new Royals stadium closer to downtown Kansas City spurred thousands of fans to join a Facebook site rallying to keep the current stadium. The hefty public financing forms part of their objection. (AP Photo/Charlie Riedel, File)
FILE - Kansas City Royals baseball team officials and their consultants talk about proposals for a new stadium to replace Kaufmann Stadium which has been home to the team for more than 50 years during a news conference, Tuesday, Aug. 22, 2023, in Kansas City, Mo. The proposal to build a new Royals stadium closer to downtown Kansas City spurred thousands of fans to join a Facebook site rallying to keep the current stadium. The hefty public financing forms part of their objection. (AP Photo/Charlie Riedel, File)
FILE - The Tennessee Titans play an NFL football game against the Houston Texans at Nissan Stadium in Nashville, Tenn., Sept. 16, 2018. Proposals for new and improved sports stadiums are proliferating across the U.S. — and could come with a hefty price tag for taxpayers. The Titans new $2.1 billion domed stadium includes $760 million in local bonds the Nashville City Council approved to go with $500 million in state bonds.(AP Photo/James Kenney, File)
FILE - The Tennessee Titans play an NFL football game against the Houston Texans at Nissan Stadium in Nashville, Tenn., Sept. 16, 2018. Proposals for new and improved sports stadiums are proliferating across the U.S. — and could come with a hefty price tag for taxpayers. The Titans new $2.1 billion domed stadium includes $760 million in local bonds the Nashville City Council approved to go with $500 million in state bonds.(AP Photo/James Kenney, File)
FILE - Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers signs Assembly Bill 438 and Assembly Bill 439 at American Family Field Tuesday, Dec. 5, 2023, in Milwaukee. Proposals for new and improved sports stadiums are proliferating across the U.S. — and could come with a hefty price tag for taxpayers. (AP Photo/Morry Gash)
FILE - Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers signs Assembly Bill 438 and Assembly Bill 439 at American Family Field Tuesday, Dec. 5, 2023, in Milwaukee. Proposals for new and improved sports stadiums are proliferating across the U.S. — and could come with a hefty price tag for taxpayers. (AP Photo/Morry Gash)
Ken Rettberg, a longtime Oakland A’s fan, is frustrated by the baseball team’s planned departure for Las Vegas and the taxpayer dollars that are subsidizing new sports venues. Pleasant Hill, Calif. Dec. 19, 2023. (AP Photo/Terry Chea)
Ken Rettberg, a longtime Oakland A’s fan, is frustrated by the baseball team’s planned departure for Las Vegas and the taxpayer dollars that are subsidizing new sports venues. Pleasant Hill, Calif. Dec. 19, 2023. (AP Photo/Terry Chea)
Standing on a portable stage erected at home plate of the Milwaukee Brewers ballpark, Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers recently praised the professional baseball team as an “essential part” of the state’s “culture and identity” and “economic success.”
With fanfare, Evers then signed off on $500 million in public aid for the stadium’s renovation, adding to a remarkable run of such blockbuster deals. This year alone, about a dozen Major League Baseball and National Football League franchises took steps toward new or improved stadiums.
A new wave of sports facility construction is underway. One driven, in part, by a race to keep up with rivals and one that could collectively cost taxpayers billions of dollars despite skepticism from economists that stadiums boost local economies.
Though the Brewers primarily cited a need for repairs, many of the other new projects are much more than that. In some cases, sports teams are even seeking a new jolt of public funding for state-of-the-art stadiums while public entities are still paying off debt from the last round of renovations a couple of decades ago.
“These facilities are not physically obsolete. It’s not as if the concrete is falling down and people are in grave danger if they attend a game,” said Rob Baade, a retired economics professor at Lake Forest College in Illinois.
“Teams are clamoring for new stadiums because it’s in their economic interest to do so,” Baade said, adding, “The new stadium model is one that spills over the stadium walls.”
THE POWER OF PEER PRESSURE
New or improved stadiums provide team owners with fresh revenue opportunities from luxury suites, dining, shopping and other developments, especially for those who control the nearby area.
For many, Los Angeles Rams owner Stan Kroenke is the model: His $5 billion football stadium opened in 2020 as the centerpiece of a sprawling development that will feature apartments, offices, retail stores, public parks and a theater.
The difference, however, is that Kroenke is privately financing the project, after uprooting the Rams from a publicly funded stadium in St. Louis that was still being paid off.
The Kansas City Royals in August unveiled two options for a new $1 billion baseball stadium as part of an overall $2 billion development. The Tampa Bay Rays followed suit in September, unveiling plans for a $1.3 billion baseball stadium as the centerpiece of a $6.5 billion development in St. Petersburg, Florida, that also features housing, retail stores, restaurants and bars and a Black history museum.
They joined the Jacksonville Jaguars, the Buffalo Bills and the Tennessee Titans, all of whom announced plans for or began construction on new billion-dollar football stadiums with luxury amenities.
Those projects all also came with public funding, including the $760 million in local bonds the Nashville City Council approved to go with $500 million in state bonds to pay for the Titans’ new $2.1 billion stadium. As part of the deal, the Titans agreed to pay off the remaining $30 million of public debt owed for their current stadium, which opened in 1999.
As the Baltimore Ravens announced a publicly funded $430 million renovation this month, the football team’s senior vice president for stadium operations said the facility is “already considered by many to be top-of-line.” But “we must remain cutting-edge and captivating,” Rich Tamayo said.
The trend extends beyond baseball and football.
On Dec. 12, Oklahoma City voters approved a 1-cent sales tax for a new Thunder basketball team arena costing at least $900 million. The next day, Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin announced a proposed $2 billion development to lure basketball’s Washington Wizards and hockey’s Washington Capitals to a new arena surrounded by a performing arts center, hotels, convention center, housing and retail stores.
The emerging cycle of stadium construction has a “level of extravagance that has ratcheted up tremendously” and is projected to peak around 2030, said J.C. Bradbury, an economics professor at Kennesaw State University in Georgia who has been tracking the projects.
FEARS OF TEAMS LEAVING
Underlying the pitch for new stadiums is an assumption that teams may head elsewhere if they don’t get what they want, a rare yet realistic possibility highlighted by MLB’s approval last month for the Oakland Athletics to relocate from California to Las Vegas.
The team’s new $1.5 billion baseball stadium in Nevada is being aided by $380 million in public funding. It will be built not far from the $2 billion football home of the Las Vegas Raiders, which opened in 2020 with $750 million of public funding from hotel room taxes.
The Raiders and A’s previously shared Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum, which had been renovated at taxpayer expense in the 1990s to lure the Raiders back from Los Angeles. The remaining $13.5 million in public debt from that renovation is to be paid off by February 2025, by which time both teams could be gone.
Longtime A’s fan Ken Rettberg is frustrated by both the A’s impending departure and the lavish public aid benefitting wealthy team owners.
“It’s crazy ... how they can get away with giving away taxpayer money. It’s completely absurd,” said Rettberg, a software engineer who lives near Oakland.
Wisconsin officials feared the Brewers also could leave, taking their tax dollars with them.
While approving public aid for the Brewers stadium on Dec. 5, Evers asserted that “losing this team would have had a ripple effect felt by families and communities across this state.” He said the team generates billions of dollars of annual economic impact and supports thousands of jobs.
Brewers principal owner Mark Attanasio said other cities inquired, but “we never considered going anywhere else.” Records show the Brewers spent $575,000 lobbying lawmakers from January through June.
American Family Field, home of the Brewers, opened in 2001 during the peak of the last round of nationwide stadium construction, as cities replaced multipurpose facilities with glitzier sport-specific structures. Public funding covered nearly three-quarters of the $392 million cost.
Wisconsin’s latest stadium deal includes nearly $674 million for renovations, including a total of about $500 million from the state, county and city.
A PUBLIC BACKLASH
Ultimately, not everyone supports efforts to renovate or replace stadiums, or the trend of asking taxpayers to bear the cost.
The Titans’ new stadium carries the nation’s largest public subsidy for a professional sports facility. But voters delivered a rebuke in September, electing a progressive councilman who voted against the subsidy to serve as mayor.
The Chicago Bears in February bought a former suburban horse racing track as a potential site for a new football stadium and surrounding development but have yet to go forward with the potentially controversial move from downtown. The Illinois Sports Facilities Authority still owes $589 million through 2032 on public bonds issued for a renovation of the Bears’ current stadium two decades ago.
Many economists contend public funding for stadiums isn’t worth it, because sports tend to divert discretionary spending away from other forms of entertainment rather than generate new income.
“When you ask economists should we fund sports stadiums, they can’t say ‘no’ fast enough,” Bradbury said. “Yet when you ask a politician, they can’t say ‘yes’ fast enough.”
Public opinion appears mixed.
A survey conducted last year for the Global Sport Institute at Arizona State University found professional sports teams were viewed as a necessary cultural component of communities by 60% of respondents. Yet fewer than half believed state and local governments should provide public funds for sports stadiums.
The proposal to build a new Royals stadium closer to downtown Kansas City spurred thousands of fans to join a Facebook site rallying to keep the current stadium. The hefty public financing forms part of their objection.
“We’ve got a perfectly good stadium sitting there that was recently renovated and we’re still paying on that,” said Royals fan Jim Meyer, an administrator of the website. He added, “There is no real reason to replace it.”